The 7 Highest Grocery Store Markups: Tips To Help You Save

The Highest Markups At The Grocery Store - woman with a loaf of french bread from the bakery; spices on a shelf; bag of breakfast cereal — If you aren’t sure which items to buy and which ones to skip at the grocery store, here is some good advice.

Shedding Light On Grocery Store Markups

Our collective quest to get the most bang for our buck at the grocery store is never truly finished. In today’s blog post, we’re continuing that quest by exploring the subject of grocery store markups.

While markups are an inescapable part of the retail experience, not all markups are created equal. And nowhere is this more true than at the grocery store, where markups can vary as widely as the variety of items they sell!

Today I’ll be shedding some light on some of the steepest markups at the grocery store and offering tips and alternatives that can save you money. While the average grocery store markup is around 15%, individual items can be marked up a lot more than that — up to 75% in some cases. We’ll look at some of the items with the highest markups below.

For even more tips and tricks for saving money at the grocery store, be sure to check out my eBook Grocery Guru, available in my shop and free to download for OGT Plus members!

7 Of The Highest Markups At The Grocery Store (And How To Avoid Them)

The Highest Markups At The Grocery Store - loose batteries on a cloth — One simple switch can save you a lot of money on batteries.

1. Batteries

Most people only buy batteries when they need them, and retailers know that. Markups on batteries are relatively high (about 70%), because they know you’re probably going to buy them regardless of the price!

You can get around the steep grocery store prices for batteries by buying in bulk at a warehouse store like Costco or Sam’s Club. Making this simple switch can save you up to 40 cents per battery!

The Highest Markups At The Grocery Store - loose carrots — If it’s not on sale, save it for another time in your meal planning.

2. Produce

Retailers also mark up produce pretty steeply, by around 50-75%, mainly to protect their profit margins from losses due to spoilage. (On average, about 20% of produce at grocery stores gets thrown out due to spoilage.)

An easy way to save money on produce is to focus on what’s on sale at the time you go grocery shopping. Sale prices on produce are typically applied to items that are available in abundance and are in-season in the location they’re grown. (It’s also smart to stock up on produce when it’s on sale and freeze it to use later!)

The Highest Markups At The Grocery Store - woman looking at grapes in a grocery store — Saving time on prepping produce = more expensive grocery trips.

3. Pre-Cut Produce

If the markup on produce is considered high, then the markup on pre-cut produce is almost off the charts! You can pay up to three times more for the convenience of pre-cut or pre-sliced fruits and vegetables than what you’d pay for those same fruits and vegetables in the produce section.

As convenient as pre-cut fruits and veggies can be, those markups can eat up a good portion of your grocery budget. To save money, plan to take a few minutes when you get home from the supermarket to cut your produce items.

The Highest Markups At The Grocery Store - a bunch of bottled water in a fridge — Save your bottled water purchases for special occasions like picnics and sporting events.

4. Bottled Water

No list of items with the highest markups would be complete without bottled water. No matter how much you buy at once or the size of the container, there’s no getting around the fact that you’re paying hundreds of times more for bottled water than you would for tap water.

If you regularly buy bottled water, you can start saving money immediately by carrying and refilling a reusable water bottle instead. (And that would still be true even if you invested in a water filtering dispenser too!)

The Highest Markups At The Grocery Store - tootie fruities cereal on a counter — These bags don’t stack up as nicely in your pantry as boxes, but your bank account will thank you.

5. Cereal

Cereal is a staple in many households, including mine! But our love of breakfast cereals can come at a cost, to the tune of a 40% markup on average.

Luckily, there are plenty of ways to save money on our favorite breakfast cereals! Sales and coupons are extremely common for cereal, so you won’t have to wait long for a good deal to stock up.

And don’t forget about store brands — these low-cost alternatives are often just as tasty as the name brand stuff!

The Highest Markups At The Grocery Store - woman looking at a loaf of a french bread in a grocery store — When in comes to baked goods, homemade is best for taste and finances.

6. Baked Goods

As convenient as those ready-made pies, cakes, and muffins in the bakery section of the grocery store can be, they aren’t always worth the cost. In fact, the markup on baked goods is often around 100%!

Many of the items are easy to replicate at home, whether from scratch or using a mix from a box. You’re sure to save quite a bit of money by going the homemade route for baked goods!

The Highest Markups At The Grocery Store - spices in a cabinet — Generic brands are your best friend at the grocery checkout stand.

7. Spices

I dread running out of any of my go-to dried herbs and spices, simply because I know I’ll have to shell out $5 or more to replace them! Spices have consistently high markups, but there are a few ways to save money on them.

One of the best money-saving options for spices is buying in bulk, which you can typically do at health food stores like Whole Foods and some standard grocery stores. The prices are much lower for bulk spices versus the jarred ones, plus you have the freedom to buy as much or as little as you need.

You can also save money by picking the generic or private label spices over the name brand options.

More Ways To Save At The Grocery Store